McKay Manor

1473 East McKay Road, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Verified
Page info provided by

Last updated Jul 24, 2026


For residents and staff
(317) 398-3100
For pricing and availability
(855) 866-7661

Pricing for McKay Manor

Pricing starts from
$2,055/mo

Your monthly costs at McKay Manor will vary depending on room type and the level of care needed. Click the button below to connect with your Seniorly Local Advisor for more accurate pricing.

Wondering if home care might be a better fit?
Sometimes staying at home with personalized care can be the better choice. Compare home care and assisted living options to see what fits your needs.

About McKay Manor

McKay Manor is an Independent Living community in the Shelbyville area. Costs for this community start at $2,055/mo, which is lower than the cost of care in the Shelbyville area of $4,283/mo.

Nestled amidst serene farmland, McKay Manor offers a tranquil senior living experience with a touch of elegance. This vibrant community is more than just a place to reside; it's a haven where residents can truly feel at home. With the picturesque landscape providing a beautiful backdrop, residents are encouraged to indulge in leisurely strolls and take in the natural beauty surrounding them. The health and well-being of residents are a top priority at McKay Manor. The community offers comprehensive medical services, including a 24-hour call system and medication management, ensuring peace of mind for both residents and their families. With a dedicated team on hand, personalized care is readily available, fostering an atmosphere of safety and security. Beyond the comforts of home, McKay Manor boasts an impressive dining experience that rivals the finest restaurants. The culinary team crafts menus that cater to various dietary needs, ensuring every meal is both delicious and nutritious. Residents have the opportunity to provide feedback, allowing for a truly personalized dining experience. The neighborhood surrounding McKay Manor is rich with amenities and conveniences. Local physicians and pharmacies, such as Indiana Hearing Aid Company and Walgreens, are just a stone's throw away, making healthcare easily accessible. For those looking to explore, nearby cafes like Just Peachy Cafe and restaurants such as El Meson Mexican Restaurant offer delightful dining options. The community's scheduled transportation service makes it easy for residents to embark on adventures, whether it's a quick coffee run or a day trip into Indianapolis. The spirit of the community is further enriched by a plethora of activities and events. From happy hours and bingo nights to cultural excursions and live entertainment, there's always something happening at McKay Manor. Residents can also enjoy peaceful moments in the library or engage in friendly games in the activity room. The community's pet-friendly policy ensures that furry companions are part of the family too. Residents and their families have expressed positive sentiments about the warmth and hospitality found at McKay Manor. The community's commitment to providing a nurturing environment is evident in every detail, from the attentive staff to the meticulously maintained grounds. McKay Manor stands as a testament to the ideal senior living experience, where care, community, and comfort come together in perfect harmony.


AI-generated description based on Seniorly's proprietary data. Contact a Seniorly representative to learn more.

About Tutera Senior Living

Average Rating
4.3
(17 reviews)

McKay Manor is part of the Tutera Senior Living portfolio of communities. 
Founded in 1985 by Dominic F. Tutera, M.D., Tutera Senior Living & Health Care provides personalized senior living experiences guided by its YOUNITE philosophy, which prioritizes resident needs and preferences. Rooted in integrity, accountability, and commitment, Tutera fosters physical, emotional, spiritual, and intellectual well-being. With Tutera University training programs and nearly 40 years of leadership under CEO Joe Tutera, the organization ensures clinical excellence and compassionate care. Families trust Tutera’s vibrant communities to empower seniors to thrive at every stage of life. Tutera Senior Living Communities have an average rating of 4.3 out of 5 stars on Seniorly.

See all Tutera Senior Living communities

Request a tour at McKay Manor

Morning (between 8AM and 12PM)

Care at McKay Manor

Care services

  • Medication management
  • Incontinence care
  • 24-hour supervision

Reviews of McKay Manor

8.6
Seniorly Community Score
Based on Seniorly's proprietary scoring, including 13 reviews across the web.

What families are saying

We’ve gathered and summarized real family reviews from across the internet for you. Contact a Seniorly representative for details.
McKay Manor receives generally positive feedback from residents and their families, highlighting its well-managed community, friendly staff, and vibrant social atmosphere. Many appreciate the spacious apartments and the independence they offer, with the option to cook in-room or enjoy meals in the dining room. The facility is praised for its cleanliness, active community, and diverse activities that foster a family-like environment. Residents often mention the helpfulness and kindness of the staff, who are quick to assist when needed. The director of sales is noted for going above and beyond, offering virtual tours and personalized shopping experiences for prospective residents. However, some reviews point out areas for improvement, particularly regarding the food quality and limited menu options. A few residents express dissatisfaction with the additional charge for in-room dining due to medical needs. There are also isolated complaints about the cleanliness of the building and the demeanor of some staff members. Despite these concerns, many residents and their families recommend McKay Manor for its affordability, independence, and supportive environment. Overall, McKay Manor is seen as a great option for those seeking senior living with a balance of independence and support. The community's active lifestyle, combined with the attentive care from staff, makes it a desirable choice for many, although potential residents are encouraged to visit and assess the facility personally to ensure it meets their specific needs and expectations.
Activities
Care Services
Cleanliness
Facilities
Dining Services
Resident Satisfaction
Staff
Value

Reviews left on Seniorly
Add a review and help other families
There are currently no reviews here for this community.
Write a review

Ask a local senior living advisor a question

Seniorly offers a free consultation with a local senior living advisor who lives in your area and knows all the information about senior living communities near you. So go ahead and ask - they're here to help!

Jane DiSalle
Jane DiSalle
Shelbyville Seniorly Advisor
  • 5 (8 reviews)
  • Families helped: 11696
  • 17 years of experience
  • Top advisor: 2024, 2025
  • Need help sooner?
    Call us at (855) 866-7661

    Amenities at McKay Manor

    Room amenities

    • Private bathroom
    • Wi-Fi / high-speed internet
    • Kitchenette

    Community amenities

    • Day trips
    • Movie nights
    • Outdoor programs

    Community services

    • Housekeeping
    • Move-in coordination
    • Laundry service / dry cleaning

    Dining services

    • Dining room
    • All day dining
    • Restaurant-style dining

    Nearby communities

    We think you might like these nearby communities
    These are recommended communities nearby McKay Manor
    Explore more communities in Shelbyville

    Seniorly Neighborhood Insights

    What you need to know for Shelbyville, IN (46176)

    Total population: 633

    50% of population is 50+ years old, 36% is 65+ years old
    The poverty rate is 6% higher for this region compared to the Indiana state average, which is 12%

    Diversity

    2% of population identify themselves as Black, 0% as Asian, 1% as Hispanic, and 96% as White

    Disclaimer

    Seniorly is not affiliated with the owner or operator(s) of McKay Manor. The information above has not been verified or approved by the owner or operator. For exact details, connect to a Seniorly Local Advisor in Shelbyville by calling (855) 866-7661. There is no cost for this service. We are compensated by the community you select.
    Are you an owner or operator of this community?

    Claim this profile to update pricing and community information.

    Explore top cities near McKay Manor